News
New figures show almost 1 in 5 trials for rape/attempted result in Not Proven
New figures released today by the Scottish Government show that almost one in five trials for rape or attempted rape result in a Not Proven verdict.
The figures also show a fall in the number of prosecutions but a slight increase in the number of convictions.
• Almost one in five rape and attempted rape trials result in a not proven verdict.
• 43% of rape and attempted rape trials result in a conviction.
Rape & Attempted Rape |
2015/16 |
2016/17 |
2017/18 |
Reported |
1809 |
1878 |
2255 |
Prosecuted |
216 |
251 |
247 |
Convicted |
105 |
99 |
107 |
% of cases prosecuted resulting in conviction |
48.6% |
39% |
43.3% |
% of cases resulting in Not Proven |
21% |
17% |
19% |
Sandy
Brindley from Rape Crisis Scotland said
“The conviction rate for rape and attempted rape continues to be the lowest for
any crime type. It is clear that much more needs to be done to improve
access to justice for people in Scotland who have been raped. The figures
speak for themselves – in 2017/18, there were 2,255 rapes and attempted rapes
reported to the police, but only 107 convictions. Reporting rape, and
going through the criminal justice process, can be an extremely difficult
experience. Survivors routinely tell us that they feel completely let
down by the justice system.
It is time
to consider whether the not proven verdict needs to go.
Many survivors
have told us is that the reality of this verdict can be devastating. It’s a
verdict which is used disproportionately in rape cases and it has exactly the
same impact as not guilty in terms of acquitting the accused. Our concern is
that the not proven verdict can give jurors in rape trials an easy out.
We also need to look at jury attitudes, and the role that myths about rape may be playing in jury decision making in these cases.”
Related posts
Why Scotland needs Specialist Sexual Offences Courts
We welcome the Bill’s introduction of a new court but there is more the Scottish Government could do.
Why we support single judge trials
Here’s why we support the pilot scheme and how we think it could help survivors.
Ask an Advocacy Worker
We spoke with two Jo and Dawn from RASASH to find out what Advocacy Workers want survivors to know.
"To all of the women and girls out there, I stand with you" - Reflections From A Survivor
Reflections From A Survivor
International Day for the Elimination of Violence Against Women '21
This blog is dedicated to the women of the Survivor Reference Group who so powerfully shared their stories in the Scottish Parliament.